When it’s time to replace your roof, choosing the right material can feel overwhelming. Each option has its strengths, drawbacks, and its unique charm. At Scotty’s Exteriors, we understand how vital this decision is—not just for protecting your home but for enhancing its look and value. Whether you’re drawn to the classic appeal of asphalt roofing, the sleek durability of metal, or the rustic elegance of cedar shake, our team is here to provide insight so that you are better able to decide which option will work best for you.

Why Your Roofing Choice Matters

Your roof is more than just a protective shield against the elements. It’s a major player in your home’s curb appeal, energy efficiency, and overall longevity. Durable, high-quality roofing can save you money on repairs, improve your home’s insulation, and even increase its resale value. That’s why picking the right material matters—and why Scotty’s Exteriors is here to make sure your roofing project is done right from start to finish.

Now, let’s break down the three most popular roofing materials we offer and discuss their key features.

Asphalt Shingles

The Classic and Affordable Choice

If practicality and affordability top your list of priorities, asphalt shingles are a standout option. Asphalt roofing is the most popular choice for homeowners across the country—and it’s easy to see why. At Scotty’s Exteriors, we frequently recommend asphalt shingles for clients seeking a reliable, cost-effective solution.

Pros of Asphalt Roofing:

• Affordability – Asphalt shingles are budget-friendly while still meeting industry standards for durability.
• Variety of Styles – They come in various colors and textures to match nearly any home style.
• Ease of Installation – Installing asphalt shingles is straightforward, and maintenance is relatively hassle-free.
• Longevity – With proper installation and maintenance, asphalt roofs can last between 20 to 30 years.

Cons to Consider:

• Asphalt doesn’t last as long as metal or cedar shake.
• It may be less eco-friendly, as it isn’t easily recyclable.
• Extreme weather conditions can cause cracking or damage.

For homeowners looking for a practical, no-fuss roof that balances function and style, asphalt shingles are a solid choice. Our team at Scotty’s Exteriors has years of experience installing and repairing asphalt roofs, ensuring you get a worry-free, long-lasting solution.

Metal Roofing

The Durable, Modern Solution

If you’re in the market for a sleek, durable roof that can withstand Minnesota’s variable weather, a metal roofing system might be your ideal pick. Metal roofs have surged in popularity because they offer impressive longevity paired with low maintenance requirements.

Pros of Metal Roofing:

• Exceptional Durability – Metal roofs can last 40–70 years or more, standing strong against wind, snow, and hail.
• Energy Efficiency – Reflective coatings help improve insulation, reducing your energy bills in both winter and summer.
• Sustainability – Many metal roofs are made from recyclable materials, making them an eco-friendly choice.
• Low Maintenance – Rust-resistant finishes and solid design mean less upkeep over its lifetime.
• Modern Aesthetic – Metal roofing lends a sleek, contemporary look to homes.

Cons to Consider:

• Higher upfront costs compared to asphalt or cedar shake.
• Noise during heavy rain can be an issue without proper insulation.
• Metal roofs expand and contract in response to temperature changes, which could require specialized installation techniques.

Scotty’s Exteriors specializes in high-quality metal roofing installations. We’ll help you choose the style and finish that suits your home while ensuring the roofing system is expertly crafted to last for decades.

Cedar Shake Roofing

Timeless Elegance Meets Natural Beauty

For those who value aesthetics and a touch of luxury, cedar shake roofing offers warmth and charm unlike any other material. A well-installed cedar shake roof is a statement piece, adding rustic beauty to your home while delivering solid protection.

Pros of Cedar Shake Roofing:

• Natural Aesthetic – Cedar shake roofing adds a distinct, timeless look to any home.
• Insulation Benefits – Wood provides natural insulation, keeping your home cooler in summer and warmer in winter.
• Durability – Cedar is naturally resistant to rot, insects, and UV damage, with a lifespan of 30–50 years if properly maintained.
• Eco-Friendly – A biodegradable and sustainable roofing material when sourced responsibly.

Cons to Consider:

• Cedar shake is one of the most expensive roofing options.
• Regular maintenance is required to prevent mold and debris buildup.
• Susceptibility to fire can be a concern, though fire-resistant treatments are available.

If you’re drawn to the elegance of cedar shake, Scotty’s Exteriors is here to bring your vision to life. We source high-quality materials and utilize expert installation techniques for a roof that is as functional as it is eye-catching.

How to Decide on the Best Roofing Material

Bringing all these factors together, deciding between asphalt, metal, and cedar shake roofing largely depends on your individual needs, budget, and aesthetic preferences. Here’s how to approach your decision:

1. Consider Your Budget – Asphalt is great for those working with tighter budgets, while metal and cedar shake are pricier investments with longer lifespans.
2. Think About Durability – Metal stands resilient, especially in areas with harsh weather conditions. However, cedar shake can hold its own and looks stunning while doing so.
3. Prioritize Maintenance – Asphalt and metal are both lower-maintenance options, while cedar shake will need more attention over time.
4. Aesthetic Goals – Think about how the roofing material complements your home’s style. Cedar shake works wonderfully with rustic or traditional homes, while metal offers a modern edge.

Why Choose Scotty’s Exteriors for Your Roofing Project?

At Scotty’s Exteriors, we don’t just install roofs—we deliver peace of mind. Our team of experts works closely with homeowners to understand their needs and provide customized solutions best suited to their homes. Whether you need a roof replacement, repair, or professional guidance in selecting a material, we’ve got you covered.

Here’s why clients trust us:

• Expert Installation – We ensure precise craftsmanship, no matter the roofing material.
• Top-Tier Materials – We source only high-quality materials to maximize durability and performance.
• Customer-Focused Approach – Your satisfaction is our priority. We listen, educate, and work tirelessly to bring your vision to life.
• Comprehensive Services – From inspections to full replacements, we’re your one-stop shop for all things roofing.

Make the Best Choice for Your Home

Choosing the right roofing material doesn’t have to be daunting. Asphalt, metal, and cedar shake each offer unique benefits, meaning there’s an option perfectly tailored to your home, style, and budget. At Scotty’s Exteriors, we’re here to guide you every step of the way, ensuring you feel confident and informed.

If you’re ready to transform your roof or need expert advice, contact us today. Our experienced team is just a call away, delivering roofing solutions that last, protect, and enhance your home for years to come.